Select Page

This Bad Boss Wept When Her Employee Accused Her of Racial Bias — Then Found a Reason to Fire the Worker

Ruby Mohamed created training courses for the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), a global organization that teaches professionals how to run HR and build “better workplaces.”

After several solid years she was promoted and assigned to a new boss, Carolyn Barley. But trouble arose: Barley treated Mohamed — an Egyptian-born Black woman — differently than her white teammates, according to later court testimony, micromanaging her work and giving her less slack on deadlines.

Mohamed complained to a higher-up, who arranged a meeting between the two women. At the meeting Mohamed explained her concerns to Barley, who is white — and Barley wept, according to testimony.

Her tears set a tone: Barley saw herself as the victim and explained to other employees that she “can’t be racist” because she has a Hispanic son, according to testimony.

An internal mediator later told Mohamed that Barley had continued “crying rivers” about the bias accusation, Mohamed testified, and the mediator seemed to hold Mohamed responsible for the resulting tension.

Barley testified that she wanted Mohamed to be “held accountable.” She set Mohamed a tough deadline for two complex projects, jurors heard. When Mohamed complained that the new deadline was retaliatory, an HR manager began drafting her termination documents, according to testimony.

Mohamed turned in the projects on time, the court heard — and a sympathetic white teammate deliberately missed the same deadline so that Barley couldn’t claim that Mohamed had underperformed her colleagues.

Barley fired Mohamed anyway, calling her work inadequate. The white employee wasn’t disciplined.

Carolyn Barley is our Bad Boss of the Month.

Mohamed sued SHRM in federal court, claiming illegal discrimination and retaliation. During a five-day trial in Colorado in late 2025, Mohamed’s lawyers argued that SHRM’s knowledge of HR standards bolstered the case for punitive damages. The jury awarded Mohamed $11.5 million in total damages, including $1.5 million for the emotional toll and $10 million that was labeled as punitive.

SHRM disputed the hefty award and asked for a new trial, but in April 2026 the trial judge accepted the jurors’ verdict, saying that it was reasonable for them to conclude that SHRM was a sophisticated actor that had, among other things, tried to “concoct evidence” in the case.

The case is now under appeal at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

Mohamed grew up in Alexandria, Egypt. She came to the U.S. at 16 as an exchange student, she testified, and studied political science at the University of Central Arkansas. After graduation she moved to Washington, D.C., where she worked for the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and later built online courses for women’s-rights activists in the Middle East.

In 2016, Mohamed joined SHRM as an e-learning specialist, building virtual, self-paced courses for HR professionals. She then switched to being an instructional designer, handling not only virtual seminars but also in-person learning experiences. Her courses were well-received, she testified; one was featured at a major SHRM conference.

Mohamed moved to Denver in 2019, working remotely and getting promoted under Barley, a former peer who had recently become a manager herself. Problems quickly emerged. Despite praising Mohamed in an early performance review, Barley kept inserting herself into Mohamed’s communications with outside experts and insisted on attending meetings that she’d typically allow white team members to run by themselves, Mohamed testified.

“I need to be there to help you sound more assertive,” Barley told her, according to Mohamed.

Barley didn’t allow Mohamed to present project updates to SHRM senior managers, Mohamed testified, even though white team members gave such reports. Barley also claimed some of Mohamed’s ideas as her own, withheld project information, and assigned her trivial tasks that should have been handled by vendors, jurors heard.

At first Mohamed tried to brush off Barley’s treatment. “I thought surely, eventually, when she sees my credibility through my work, she will lay off a little bit,” she testified.

But then George Floyd was murdered and — amid a SHRM-wide gut check on racial justice — Jeanne Morris, Barley’s boss and Mohamed’s mentor, directly asked Mohamed how she was doing. Mohamed saw Morris as her “safe person,” she told jurors, and she decided to share her frustrations about Barley’s management.

“I have to prove my worth at every single task,” she recalled telling Morris, while “white peers were just granted [trust] without any kind of stress.”

Morris arranged a virtual meeting between the two women. Mohamed testified that she tried hard to ensure that Barley wouldn’t feel “that she’s getting attacked … I sincerely wanted her to hear me out.” But it didn’t go well.

According to court documents, Barley hadn’t slept the previous night because she was fretting about what Mohamed would say — and then, not long before the meeting, she learned of a death in the family. Barley didn’t mention this to Morris and Mohamed, but all three participants agree that Barley became very emotional.

She cried, Barley acknowledged on the stand.

Further sessions with Barley and other managers followed but didn’t help much. Barley allowed Mohamed to attend some meetings alone, the jury heard, but tensions simmered. One of Mohamed’s white peers, Carrie Mills, testified that Barley told her to get feedback from colleagues on a race-related project — but not to ask Mohamed.

“I couldn’t understand why someone on a team could produce quality work and be treated so poorly, so consistently. I was afraid that there was something larger at play,” Mills said in court.

In team meetings, Mills testified, Barley’s dealings with Mohamed grew “very critical, very pointed. It was as if the point was to humiliate her.” Ultimately, Mills told jurors, she reported to a SHRM official that Barley “was acting out of racist intent.”

In July 2020 SHRM managers convened a group meeting for Mohamed and others to describe their interactions with Barley. Mohamed told jurors she believed it was an empty exercise, and she balked at repeating her traumatic experience — even after the team’s only other person of color, Ebony Thompson, said that Barley was treating her differently, too.

Pressured to participate, Mohamed ended up sobbing as she recounted her feelings without any hope of meaningful change, she testified. The following day, she told jurors, her mentor Jeanne Morris disputed some of what she’d said during the session. It sealed her disillusionment.

“I didn’t want to talk about this anymore,” Mohamed testified. “I just wanted to be left alone. [It was] getting in the way of me just — of my well-being as an individual.”

She asked for eight days off.

Meanwhile, Barley had been advised by an HR manager to keep notes on her interactions with Mohamed. In this paper trail, which was filed in court, Barley portrays herself as the victim. “I’m feeling harassed or bullied,” she wrote, refusing to apologize to Mohamed because the claim of discrimination was “not true.”

Barley sat close to Mills, Mohamed’s white coworker, in SHRM’s office in Virginia. Mills testified that Barley kept complaining about the injustice of Mohamed’s claims, usually at a high emotional pitch.

“Frantic is probably the best word” for Barley’s demeanor, Mills told jurors. “She would become flushed and red in the cheeks.”

“She would say things like, ‘I can’t be racist. I have a Hispanic son,'” Mills testified. “She asked me many times if Ruby is even Black.”

“I’m so upset,” Barley wrote in her notes. “These accusations have no justification. … I am not sure how I can get [past] this knowing a colleague can threaten me and not be held accountable.”

When Mohamed returned after her break, there were three notable changes.

First, Mohamed learned that Ebony Thompson, the team’s other Black person, was gone from SHRM. “I told [Mohamed] that I couldn’t discuss the details since it was a personnel matter,” Barley’s court-filed notes say, “but we wish Ebony well on her next endeavors.”

Second, Mohamed and Barley started meeting with an internal mediator. Mohamed initially welcomed this, she testified, as the mediator was a Black woman who seemed to sympathize with her. Quickly, however, the mediator let Mohamed know that Barley had been “crying rivers” in her absence — and implied that it was up to Mohamed to restore morale, Mohamed told the court.

And third, Mohamed was suddenly given a firm deadline for two large projects: August 31. According to Barley, Mohamed should expect no help.

“I cannot in good conscience delegate any portion of the programs you are currently working on to your teammates,” Barley wrote in an email to Mohamed; the deadline “is non-negotiable.”

According to testimony and court documents, this “non-negotiable” email was originally drafted for Barley by the SHRM mediator — and it was discussed among senior managers as possible support for “an eventual case for termination,” in the words of one email.

Mohamed saw that Barley was setting her up to fail, she testified, and she called it out as retaliation in an email. Two days later, an HR official at SHRM started creating paperwork for Mohamed’s termination — just to be prepared, he testified. A draft separation form listed her final day as August 31, the deadline that hadn’t yet arrived.

The official testified that the separation date didn’t “necessarily” mean that SHRM already decided to fire Mohamed. “It’s not uncommon for us to draft documents to have them available if needed,” he said.

Also in August, Barley assigned an identical end-of-month deadline to Mills, Mohamed’s white teammate — and threatened her with “career repercussions” if she didn’t meet it, Mills said in court, even though Barley “had never been strict about a deadline up until this point.”

The manager was “red-faced” as she made her demand, Mills testified. “The tone that she used with me was unlike she ever had before. — [She said] there was a larger context and reason that she could not share with me at the time.”

Mills decided to miss the deadline deliberately. “It was very obvious that this was a deadline being held to trip [Mohamed] up,” she testified. “I would not be used as a counterexample.”

In the event, Mohamed submitted both her projects by August 31 — although one was missing some modules because a contractor had failed to provide content. Barley found the work lacking, she testified, and resolved to fire Mohamed. She handed one of the projects to Mills to finish, but Mills told jurors that it was already “pretty much done” and that Barley said she hadn’t reviewed it.

“I had to make a really hard decision,” Barley told the jury, adding that she was under “huge pressures” at the time due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

On August 31, SHRM’s HR chief informed Mohamed that the organization had found her discrimination and retaliation claims to be unfounded. Barley fired her the following day.

“Something definitely broke inside of me,” Mohamed told jurors. “My ambitions were basically killed. … If that’s how management operates in the leading HR organization in the entire world, then I definitely don’t want to be part of that.”

Mohamed found a new job after three months, she testified, but her goal was “to not be seen, to work in the background. … Don’t speak up.” She didn’t even want to turn on her camera during video meetings, she said, “so people won’t see that I’m Black and [treat] me different.”

In 2022, Barley was moved to a new position with no subordinates; she left SHRM in 2024. Given the chance to do things over, she told jurors, she’d fire Mohamed again.

She still offers HR advice for a living, she told the jury.

 

» Read Mohamed’s complaint

» Read Carrie Mills’ testimony about missing her own deadline in order to protect Mohamed

 


The Employment Law Group® law firm was not involved in Mohamed v. Society for Human Resource Management. We select “Bad Boss” cases to illustrate the continuing relevance of employee protection laws for our newsletter’s audience, which includes attorneys and former TELG clients.

Mohamed was represented by Lowrey Parady Lebsack DeFazio and Swain Law LLC.


Get the Newsletter
for FREE!

Sign up for Bad Boss of the Month updates.